How Addiction Affects The Transgender Community

With the transition of athlete and reality TV star Bruce Jenner into Caitlyn Jenner and the acclaim and attention actress Laverne Cox has earned for Orange Is the New Black and other projects, the United States is more aware of and accepting of transgender people than ever before.

That hasn’t been all good news, however. Traditionalist and confused citizens and politicians have responded by barring them from the military and public restrooms that conform to their gender identity.

It’s no wonder, then, that even though transgender people make up less than 1% of the U.S. population, they make up a greater percentage of those with mental health and substance use disorders—a higher rate than the overall LGBTQ community.

What Is Gender Spectrum?

Although transgender is often grouped with lesbian, gay, bisexual, and questioning/queer, it is a distinct description and only a small part of the wider gender spectrum. It is not limited to whether you are a man or a woman.

It can be confusing for LGBTQ individuals as well as cisgender ones (people who identify with the same gender they were assigned at birth).

In a survey of LGBTQ individuals, 68% of LGBTQ respondents did identify as either man or woman—binary—and 7% as transgender binary. The other 25%, however, identified their gender with some nonbinary category along the gender spectrum.

Eleven percent thought “gender nonconforming” was most appropriate, and another 11% felt “multiple identities” was a better fit, but the other 3% chose or came up with different designations—more than 25 different gender categories—including nonbinary, queer, and genderqueer.

Not everybody who identifies as nonbinary agrees on what the term means. In general, nonbinary—often, though not universally, used interchangeably with genderqueer—refers to people who feel their gender identity isn’t simply “man” or “woman”. They may feel they fall in between the binary categories, outside of the categories, or that they move between them.

Nonbinary identity alone is not a biological distinction. It doesn’t necessarily mean you are transgender or that your genitals aren’t 100% male or female (intersex), though it can. Nonbinary—not binary—can coexist with other designations. It’s an innate feeling.

What Is Transgender?

Although transgender is often grouped with lesbian, gay, bisexual, and questioning/queer, it is a distinct description.

A transgender woman is someone who is born with male sexual characteristics but identifies as a woman. Likewise, a transgender man was born with female sexual characteristics but identifies as a man. Cisgender is a term for people whose gender identity is the same as the sex they were assigned at birth.

What makes someone a transgender individual is gender identity, how they feel inside. It’s not about what gender you are attracted to or how you like to dress (gender expression).

Transgender is a spectrum. For example, it is distinct from sexual orientation. There are gay and straight transgender people. Most transgender individuals maintain the same sexual orientation after coming out as transgender—social transitioning—as before (though some change orientation shortly before transitioning).

That identification alone makes someone transgender, but some modify their bodies to more closely resemble their gender identity with hormone replacement therapy, cosmetic surgery, or reconstructive surgery. Such gender confirmation surgery (or gender affirmation surgery) includes facial and chest modification, and vocal and genital surgery.

The realization that one is transgender may predate sexual attraction.

In December 2019, a 12-year-old in England started taking hormone blockers to prevent puberty so that she could eventually transition to a woman when she is 18. According to her mother, she had already identified as a girl by age 3. (In the United Kingdom, a child can take hormone blockers as young as 10. More than 1,000 children have done so.)

Until age 11, she went to public school, sometimes dressed as a girl (she legally changed her name from Ashton to Ashley) with the support of her school’s educators and fellow pupils.  Despite that, bullies and some other students’ parents drove her to homeschooling. She suffers from anxiety and sometimes even says she wants to die.

She’s not alone. Forty percent of respondents to the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey said they have attempted suicide at least once compared to less than 5% of the U.S. population in general.

Transgender People and Mental Health Issues

According to a 2016-2017 survey from the Human Rights Campaign, a LGBTQ rights organization, transgender depression statistics are high. The survey found that while 12% of non-LGBTQ youths felt “depressed most or all of the time” in the past 30 days, 28% of LGBTQ youths felt likewise, and 40% of transgender youths.

Since same-sex attraction in a largely heterosexual society can cause mental health issues, it is understandable that to feel that one is not in the right body can cause mood, anxiety, and substance use disorders, as well as suicidal ideation, attempts, and worse.

Among other transgender mental health statistics, rates of anxiety disorders are almost three times higher than the general population. The rate often decreases following treatment with “cross-sex hormones,” at least for transgender women. (A  greater percentage of transgender individuals seem to have autism spectrum disorder, too, though that is a neurological and developmental disorder, not one of mental health.)

Other transgender mental illness statistics have rates closer to the population in general, with no increased risk of bipolar personality disorder (BPD) or schizophrenia.

A study in Sweden found that when transgender individuals have gender confirmation surgery, the likelihood that they would seek treatment for depression or anxiety-related mental health issues declined by 8% each year. It remained higher than among the general population, however.

What Is Gender Dysphoria?

One reason depression and anxiety rates are higher among the transgender population is gender dysphoria: some people feel uncomfortable with the “sex-related physical characteristics” with which they were born.

Gender dysphoria was formerly known as gender identity disorder, though that is now considered an inaccurate designation because it implies their gender identity is the problem. In May 2019, the United Nations World Health Organization removed “gender identity disorder” from its official diagnosis manual, putting transgender in the sexuality category instead of labeling it a mental health condition.

Not all transgender individuals experience gender dysphoria. Many transgender people are content with their bodies as they are but identify as the opposite sex. Those with gender dysphoria may be more preoccupied with changing their bodies to match their gender identity.

Some want gender confirmation surgery to make their outside bodies match their inner selves, but not all. Just 10% of transgender people seeking surgery are going for genital surgery or medically transitioning. More are content with less invasive modifications such as hormone treatments, facial feminization, and male chest reconstruction.

Transgender People and Substance Use Disorder

Only 3% of people identified as being gender dysphoric in a population-based study released in 2018 were seeking treatment for substance use disorder, but alcohol and substance use is much higher than that:

  • Almost half have engaged in binge drinking, which is drinking a substantial amount of alcohol in a short amount of time (47%)
  • About 1 in 5 used illicit drugs, not including marijuana (19%)
  • More than 1 in 10 engaged in binge drinking as well as using marijuana and illicit drugs at the same time (10.8%)
  • 34% of male-to-female (MTF) transgender individuals report using intravenous drugs at some point in their lifetime, as opposed to 18% of female-to-male (FTM) individuals and 2.6% of the general U.S. population

A study, published in the Journal of School Health—based on a statewide survey of elementary, middle, and high school students—found that transgender students were:

  • Twice as likely to misuse prescription pain medication
  • Two-and-a-half times more likely to use cocaine and methamphetamine
  • Almost three times as likely to huff inhalants
  • Three times as likely to misuse opioids or smoke cigarettes in school.

Another study found that transgender abuse statistics, at least among transgender women, were even higher—as much as 4-10 times higher for alcohol, cannabis, cocaine, amphetamines, methamphetamine, and opioids—because of stigma, both self-directed and external, including discrimination and physical or psychological abuse.

Causes of Transgender Substance Abuse

Researchers in the Journal of School Health study also found that the main cause of increased transgender substance abuse isn’t gender identity or even gender dysphoria, however; it is discrimination, minority stress, and the lack of a “social support mechanism.” Substance use disorder (SUD) is sometimes a coping mechanism.

If transgendered teens or young adults do not feel accepted, if they have a mental health issue such as depression or anxiety, they may turn to illegal or illicit substance use in an attempt to self-medicate. This is known as a co-occurring disorder or a dual diagnosis.

All clients should be evaluated for co-occurring mental health issues, but transgender clients are at greater risk than most.

Transgender Substance Abuse Treatment

Transgender people are more likely than other groups or the population at large to seek SUD treatment than the non-transgender population. That doesn’t mean effective treatment is always available.

People in the transgender community need the same SUD treatment as other people—detoxification, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), aftercare, maybe medically-assisted treatment—but there have been few studies of what therapies might work better for transgender clients.

Most researchers agree that there is less information available on effective SUD treatment for bisexual and transgender clients than for other members of the LGBTQ community, even though transgender individuals are often subect to extremely negative attitudes and discrimination.

Barriers to Transgender Substance Abuse Treatment

Problems faced by transgender people with SUD include:

  • Verbal and physical abuse from other clients and staff. If not actively hostile, staff may not take action if other clients are abusive.
  • Use of their birth name (and pronoun) instead of their current chosen name. It can be psychologically damaging and unsupportive.
  • Requirements to wear only clothing or cosmetics relating to the gender they were assigned at birth. Rehabs generally prohibit provocative dress or makeup, but gender expression may be important to transgender clients and their gender identity.
  • Housing with members of the gender they were assigned at birth. Rehabs don’t always have private rooms, and some are like dormitories or barracks. Unless the entire facility is coed, it may be disrespectful to compel a transgender person to room with members of the opposite gender identity.

Such conditions are not conducive to recovery.

How to Improve Transgender SUD Rehab Outcomes

To improve the odds that transgender individuals will seek substance use and mental health treatment that succeeds in the long run, it’s better to find specifically transgender treatment centers, or at least programs.

One such program opened in November 2019 at the Gay and Lesbian Center of the Community Counseling Center of Southern Nevada.  Affirmations offers mental health counseling for the LGBTQ community. Cost isn’t a factor because it accepts state Medicaid, charges for its services on an income-based sliding scale and receives some grant funding.

Affirmations says it addresses LGBTQ clients from a compassionate, “culturally sensitive” perspective not always found in a profession where some still consider non-cisgender or transgender sexuality an illness that needs to be cured and that conversion therapy is appropriate,

Unfortunately, such centers and programs are hard to find. There are not enough transgender people in many communities to sustain a transgender-only bar, let alone a treatment center. A more achievable goal would be a treatment center that helps people and doesn’t make substance use worse.

Transgender people on staff

One program for male-to-female transgender clients in San Francisco’s Walden House employs some MTF transgender staff, including a licensed clinical social worker and an addiction counselor who is in recovery. Not only are such staff members sensitive and empathetic, but they may also serve as positive role models, since they may be the first transgender professionals the clients have encountered.

Sensitivity training for staff and clients

Because there probably are not enough transgender health care workers to staff every transgender SUD program, non-transgender employees are also needed. They may need sensitivity training to understand and address the needs of transgender clients and other diverse groups. Other clients, especially if they are not all transgender individuals, may also need some basic sensitivity training.

Peer support group

All people in recovery eventually leave treatment or at least leave their recovery centers. To maintain sobriety afterward, they need some form of aftercare, including peer support groups. Alcoholics Anonymous or Narcotics Anonymous are examples of peer support groups, while other support groups offer sobriety support without using a series of 12 steps.

If they can’t find a peer support group with other transgender people with substance use issues, transgender men and women may face a dilemma: choose a support group of other transgender people who don’t have a SUD and still drink or choose a SUD support group where the other members may not know or understand transgender issues.

Former clients of treatment centers may have or start support groups.

Community ties

Because they cannot spend all of their time in a bubble, transgender men and women will also need to interact with the non-transgender community. They need to know how to look for work and find housing. A good aftercare program will provide this sort of aid.

Transgender clients need to have their gender identity recognized and respected or they are unlikely to enter substance use disorder rehab, let alone remain for the full course of treatment or experience lasting benefits from it.

More information on transgender healthcare:

  • SAMHSA.gov – Resources for transgender individuals and others in the LGBTQ community from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
  • HHS.gov – Resources on health and wellbeing for the LGBT community from the US Department of Health & Human Services.
  • Healthcare.gov – Information on transgender healthcare and the Health Insurance Marketplace.
  • OutCare Health – The nonprofit provides a searchable database of “LGBTQ competent” physicians and other healthcare providers.

Support Hotlines & Hate Incidents

National Suicide Prevention Hotline   Crisis hotline:  800­-273-­TALK (8255); 888-­628­-9454 (en español)

Crisis Text Line – Text 741741 to speak with a trained Crisis Counselor.

The Trevor Project –  Crisis hotline: 866­-488­-7386 (for those ages 13­-24)

National Sexual Assault Hotline – Crisis hotline: 800­-656-­HOPE (4673)

The National Domestic Violence Hotline – Hotline: 800-­799-­SAFE (7233)

Communities Against Hate Report an incident. Get help at: 1-844-9-NO-HATE

Insurance & Mental Health Resources

National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) – Helpline: 800­-950-­6264

Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration –  Hotline: 800-662-HELP (4357)

Out2EnrollEnroll in insurance

Domestic Violence/Abuse Resources

Domestic Shelters – DomesticShelters.org

National Coalition of AntiViolence Programs (NCAVP) – https://avp.org/

References

  • williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu – How Many Adults Identify as Transgender in the United States
  • lgbtmap.org – Invisible Majority: The Disparities Facing Bisexual People and How to Remedy Them
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Transgender Transitioning and Change of Self-Reported Sexual Orientation
  • vox.com – 9 questions about gender identity and being transgender you were too embarrassed to ask
  • telegraph.co.uk – Transgender pupil, 12, given puberty blockers, as mother says she “wanted to be a girl from age of three”
  • news.yahoo.com – Transgender girl’s brave journey as one of the youngest children in the UK to begin the transition process
  • transequality.org– The Report of the 2015 U.S.Transgender Survey
  • suicidepreventionlifeline.org – Mental Health and the LGBTQ Community
  • researchgate.net/publication – Transgender and anxiety: A comparative study between transgender people and the general population
  • slate.com – A Disproportionate Number of Autistic Youth Are Transgender. Why?
  • medlineplus.gov – Autism Spectrum Disorder
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Mental health and gender dysphoria: A review of the literature
  • medicine.yale.edu – Mental Health Outcomes Improve for Transgender Individuals After Surgery, Study Finds
  • mayoclinic.orgGender dysphoria
  • news.un.org – A major win for transgender rights: UN health agency drops “gender identity disorder”, as official diagnosis
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Transgender Transitioning and Change of Self-Reported Sexual Orientation
  • vox.com – Myth #5: All trans people medically transition (Transgender people: 10 common myths)
  • uofmhealth.org – Gender Confirmation Surgery
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Demographic and temporal trends in transgender identities and gender confirming surgery
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Facial feminization surgery: current state of the art
  • academia.edu – Factors Which Influence Individual’s Decisions When Considering Female-To-Male Genital Reconstructive Surgery
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Substance Use and Treatment of Substance Use Disorders in a Community Sample of Transgender Adults
  • opensiuc.lib.siu.edu – The Need for Specialized Programs for LGBT Individuals in Substance Abuse Treatment
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Estimating the Number of Persons Who Inject Drugs in the United States by Meta-Analysis to Calculate National Rates of HIV and Hepatitis C Virus Infections
  • nbcnews.com – Transgender Students Face Higher Rates of Substance Abuse, Study Finds
  • ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Gender Abuse, Depressive Symptoms, and Substance Use Among Transgender Women: A 3-Year Prospective Study
  • drugabuse.gov – Substance Use and SUDs in LGBTQ* Populations
  • glaad.org – Transgender FAQ
  • cdn.atria.nl – Engaging Transgender Substance Users in Substance Use Treatment

Support Hotlines & Hate Incidents

National Suicide Prevention Hotline   Crisis hotline:  800­-273-­TALK (8255); 888-­628­-9454 (en español)

Crisis Text Line – Text 741741 to speak with a trained Crisis Counselor.

The Trevor Project –  Crisis hotline: 866­-488­-7386 (for those ages 13­-24)

National Sexual Assault Hotline – Crisis hotline: 800­-656-­HOPE (4673)

The National Domestic Violence Hotline – Hotline: 800-­799-­SAFE (7233)

Communities Against Hate Report an incident. Get help at: 1-844-9-NO-HATE

Insurance & Mental Health Resources

National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) – Helpline: 800­-950-­6264

Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration –  Hotline: 800-662-HELP (4357)

Out2EnrollEnroll in insurance

Domestic Violence/Abuse Resources

Domestic Shelters – DomesticShelters.org

National Coalition of AntiViolence Programs (NCAVP) – https://avp.org/