Many people are familiar with 12 step programs such as AA. They help people with alcohol or other substance use disorders (SUD) remain sober by meeting regularly, identifying themselves as an addict, and sharing stories of triumph and failure. The meetings are led by members, not trained therapists.
They may remain in a 12-step group all their lives to reinforce their sobriety and to serve as mentors (“sponsors”) to newer members. They also may “work the steps”: perform the actions in the 12 steps, in order and without skipping.
These steps begin with admitting they have a problem with alcohol or drugs and include making an honest inventory of their faults and bad actions, apologizing and trying to make restitution to those they have wronged, and then helping others.
How Effective Are 12-step Programs?
No one knows the success rate of 12-step programs in part because they are anonymous. One 2020 review of 35 studies found that 42% of AA participants remained sober for at least a year as opposed to those undergoing Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, which was 35%. This difference was attributed to greater retention of individuals in AA at the end of the study period. A 2000 report put the rate as low as 5% for newcomers. The study emphasized that organized and structured clinical methods are most effective. These must be used by clinicians to reap benefits from methods like 12-step programs.
It may depend on whether you count people who drop out of AA or count everyone who attends any meetings. AA’s membership surveys are snapshots in time of its recovery program that are called cross sectional studies. In 2014, the respondents’ duration of sobriety ranged from less than one year (27%) to more than 20 years (22%).
Other studies have found that 12-step programs in combination with treatments such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) can save money and produce better outcomes than either alone.
Why Choose Non-12-step Programs?
Whatever their success rate, 12-step programs are not the only option and may not be the best one. Alternative and supplemental treatments are needed because:
- The 12 steps alone are not treatment. While they are useful and valuable, by themselves, 12-step programs are fellowships, mutual aid societies, or support groups of people with a similar problem who gather to offer judgment-free moral support. They are generally not run by trained professionals.
- The 12 steps refer to God. Four of the original 12 steps refer to God directly, and another two (“Power greater than ourselves”; “Him”) indirectly. “Moral,” “prayer,” and “spiritual” also appear. Even if you remove these mentions, they are still based on faith, not science or evidence.
- 12-step programs don’t work for everyone. That doesn’t mean another program won’t work. There are other fellowships. More options increase the chances of success if they are based on sound scientific principles and have evidence of success.
Also, while AA does work with some people, not all of its principles are scientifically sound, such as what it believes causes addiction.
What Causes Addiction?
AA was an early proponent of addiction as a disease model, rather than moral weakness, but it still says that people with addictions are addicts, that they are helpless against addiction and only a higher power (and AA) can help them.
Most addiction specialists, however, now believe that addiction is only partly due to behavior. Genetic predisposition is an important factor. Environmental factors also play a role- people who have experienced trauma, physical or mental abuse, or have a pre-existing mental health issue are more likely to abuse substances.
Non-12-step addiction treatment makes individuals full partners in their recovery, assisted by science or evidence-based treatments. They need to accept responsibility for their actions but they are not helpless. The rise in substance abuse and overdose deaths is not inevitable. For example, the rate of opioid abuse among active-duty military members has been decreasing due to:
Are alcohol and drugs ruining your life? FIND HELP NOW
The rise in substance abuse and overdose deaths is not inevitable. For example, the rate of opioid abuse among active-duty military members has been decreasing due to:
What do Non 12 Step Programs Consist of?
While a non-12-step program could be any program that has fewer, more, or different steps than a 12-step program—or even none—it usually refers to a secular program that is based on evidence, not faith.
Which Groups are Considered Non 12 Step Programs?
Secular fellowships, mutual aid societies, and self-help group alternatives to the better-known 12-step programs include:
- SMART (Self-Management and Recovery Training) Recovery. A four-point secular, science-based, abstinence-based plan to cope with problems and cravings without using drugs or alcohol.
- Moderation Management (MM). A nonprofit that teaches moderation as well as abstinence from alcohol. They have a tool available to track your drinking in moderation, contented abstinence, uncomfortable abstinence, etc. This ledger can be kept private or made public to gain and lend support.
- Secular Organizations for Sobriety (SOS). A cognitive approach to recovery and abstinence with sobriety as the highest priority.
- Women for Sobriety (WFS). A non-profit only for women with substance use disorders that stresses personal responsibility and emotional and spiritual growth.
- LifeRing Secular Recovery. A permanent workshop for abstinence and personal recovery based on its “3-S” principles: Sobriety, Secularity, and Self-Help.
- Matrix Model. An intensive and inclusive therapist-driven treatment method intended primarily for those with SUDs involving stimulants such as cocaine and methamphetamine (meth).
Scientific and evidence-based programs that include medically monitored detox and talk therapies, including:
- Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT). Psychotherapy teaches how to recognize and change negative or inaccurate thinking. Also useful for mental health issues such as obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), depression and post-traumatic stress disorders.
- Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT). is a variation of CBT that is used especially for women with alcohol use disorder, especially when co-occurring with borderline personality disorder (BPD).
- Motivational enhancement therapy (MET). A method that is especially useful for alcohol use disorders but can also help people with other SUDs to overcome their resistance to seeking treatment.
- Group therapy. Similar to a peer support group but with a trained therapist guiding the meeting. Many authorities find group therapy is better than individual therapy for SUDs because the presence of peers offers challenges and support.
Medication-assisted treatments (MAT)
Drugs that are used to stop or manage the cravings for or the effects (including withdrawal pains and overdoses) of opioids to keep clients in the program until they can be weaned off them, such as:
- Methadone. A low-dose opioid that prevents withdrawal but doesn’t cause euphoria.
- Buprenorphine (Suboxone). Similar to methadone but available in many different forms, including a tamper-resistant compound that includes the opioid overdose reversal drug naloxone (Narcan) and an implant.
- Naltrexone (Vivitrol). A drug, usually in an injectable form, that blocks the effects of opioids for up to a month at a time. Someone on Vivitrol will not get high if they continue to use opioids.
- Disufiram (Antabuse): A drug that produces severe hangover-like symptoms when alcohol is consumed while on this drug. It acts as a form of negative reinforcement.
- Contingency management (CM)/Community reinforcement approach (CRA) plus vouchers. The two similar programs use a reward system—from cash and prizes to an affirmation—for staying drug- and alcohol-free. They more than double the rate of retention and sobriety.
- Holistic treatment. This type of non-12-step program focuses on improving the clients’ overall well-being with physical exercise, a healthy diet, and alternative therapies such as yoga, meditation, massage, art therapy, and equine therapy.
- Dual diagnosis treatment. This type of treatment program offers treatment for the effects of substance abuse and also for other co-occurring conditions, such as mental illnesses. If clients are diagnosed with co-occurring mental conditions, their treatment programs will be geared at simultaneously treating their mental illnesses and their addictions.
Are Non-12-Step Recovery Approaches Effective?
There have been fewer studies of non-12-step programs than 12-step, but a 2018 longitudinal study found that when abstinence was the goal (some of them include moderation as an option to abstinence), several non-12-step programs were about as successful as AA.
Moreover, the study argued that some people who were uncomfortable or just unhappy with AA might prefer one of these other programs. Some might even like to participate in AA and another program. Talk to a Intake Coordinator
Take The First Step Towards Recovery
Talk to a Intake Coordinator
Why Others Still Choose 12-Step Treatment
Twelve-step programs are a safe entry point for some people who want to overcome addiction because:
- Free. There are no membership fees, no admission fees, though a hat is passed to pay for the room rental and coffee.
- Widely available. In larger communities there are meetings every day, sometimes several times a day in different spaces.
- Replaces hanging out at the bar. If you did all your socializing at a place dedicated to alcoholic beverages, you shouldn’t go there any longer. Even if you don’t plan to drink, just being there could trigger a craving.
- Make new friends. You shouldn’t hang around people with whom you used to drink, either. Even if they’re not drinking, their presence can be a trigger.
- Famous. Everyone has heard of AA. It’s been heavily promoted by the media, doctors, judges, and politicians.
- Anonymous. People with substance use disorders often feel ashamed or persecuted for their problems. Anonymity helps them admit their problem.
- Judgment-free. Everyone has the same problem; some are just controlling it better.
- Religious. Although some people may be turned off by the references to God and faith, others take comfort from them.
Benefits of Non-12-Step Drug Rehab
What sets alternative addiction treatment programs apart from their 12-step treatment counterparts is responsibility and motivation.
According to 12-step programs, addictions stem from individuals’ bad decisions and the physical effects of the abused substances. Non-12-step treatment programs teach that addiction may not be their fault, but recovery is their responsibility. They have to do the work and maintain vigilance against a relapse.
For many clients, this approach leads to better and more effective treatment. It points them toward the causes of their addictions and empowers them to work on fixing such causes.
In non-12-step programs, people with SUDs own up to their actions and decisions and are encouraged to believe that they have full responsibility for their treatment success and recovery.
Non-12-step drug rehab programs combine addiction treatment and perspectives about mental health to provide treatments to people with substance abuse disorder. Such people often have a dual diagnosis or a condition that includes both a mental health disorder and a drug or alcohol addiction.
These non-12-step treatment approaches also provide individualized plans that are unique to each person, based on the individual’s needs and addiction. Professional counseling offered by non-12-step drug rehab often incorporates evidence-based and scientific approaches.
- wilx.com – Overdose deaths rise amid pandemic
- cdc.gov – Deaths from Excessive Alcohol Use in the U.S.
- marketwatch.com – U.S. online alcohol sales jump 243% during coronavirus pandemic
- marylandmatters.org – COVID-19 Eased Drug Treatment Rules — And That Saved Lives
- npr.org – Trump Administration Will Let More Doctors Prescribe Drug To Fight Opioid Addiction
- ajmc.com – COVID-19 Telehealth Expansion Can Help Solve the Health Care Underutilization Challenge
- aa.org/ – Welcome to Alcoholics Anonymous
- cochrane.org – New Cochrane Review finds Alcoholics Anonymous and 12-Step Facilitation programs help people to recover from alcohol problems
- theatlantic.com – The Surprising Failures of 12 Steps
- army.mil – Garrison provides support services to help with pandemic substance use
- smartrecovery.org/ – SMART Recovery
- moderation.org/ – Moderation Management
- sossobriety.org/ – Secular Organizations for Sobriety (SOS)
- womenforsobriety.org/ – Women for Sobriety: Home
- lifering.org/ – LifeRing Secular Recovery
- drugabuse.gov – The Matrix Model (Stimulants)
- mayoclinic.org – Cognitive behavioral therapy
- ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Dialectical Behavior Therapy
- drugabuse.gov – Motivational Enhancement Therapy
- drugabuse.gov – Effectiveness of psycho-educational group therapy to motivate change among addicts in the early stages of change
- webmd.com – Counseling and Addiction
- ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – Medication-Assisted Treatment for Opioid Use Disorder
- drugabuse.gov – Contingency Management
- drugabuse.gov – Community Reinforcement Approach Plus Vouchers
- researchgate.net – Contingency Management: Using Motivational Incentives to Improve Drug Abuse Treatment
- health.usnews.com – Why You Should Consider Holistic Addiction Treatment
- sunshinebehavioralhealth.com – Dual Diagnosis Addiction Treatment
- ncbi.nlm.nih.gov – A Longitudinal Study of the Comparative Efficacy of Women for Sobriety, LifeRing, SMART Recovery, and 12-step Groups for those with AUD
Sunshine Behavioral Health strives to help people who are facing substance abuse, addiction, mental health disorders, or a combination of these conditions. It does this by providing compassionate care and evidence-based content that addresses health, treatment, and recovery.
Licensed medical professionals review material we publish on our site. The material is not a substitute for qualified medical diagnoses, treatment, or advice. It should not be used to replace the suggestions of your personal physician or other health care professionals.
Talk with one of our Treatment Specialists!
Call 24/7: 949-276-2886